M3ghan (2022)
Director: Gerard Johnstone
Stars: Allison Williams, Violet McGraw, Amie Donald, Jenna
Davis (voice)
Short Review, no spoilers
When M3ghan first came out at cinemas, it seemed to be sold
as a straight-up horror movie in the sense of both another entry in the creepy
doll genre and also the latest model from production company Blumhouse. However,
it is actually a refreshingly dark and clever satire made with the kind of
smart restraint that will frustrate anyone demanding only ‘how many killins’
and ’ooh how it made me jump’ thrills when the real chill factor is how
insidiously and seductively the promotion of technology seems to promise the
solution to all of our age-old human life problems.
Full Review (spoilers)
The opening scene of M3gan was perhaps the most horrifying
for me when I first saw it at my local movie house. Thinking it was yet another
bloody tacky advert after the millions I’d already watched, I was soothed and
amused when I realised it was a satirical start to what is a very clever and
critical film. Beginning with a cheesy and hilarious commercial much like
Westworld - another robot-gone-wrong movie – here we are introduced to the
competitive arena of toy-dom. There on in the threat of AI and its hurried,
irresponsible use to make profit is again explored but here with the added complexities
of modern era child-raising.
Thus, from the beginning, we are met with bolt after bolt of
sometimes very darkly funny stabs at our increasing dependence on technology and
how it seems to have overridden common sense in various scenarios. Even the
tragic car accident that kills eight-year-old Cady’s parents at the beginning
culminates after a conversation that reveals them to be typically modern,
middle class and non-real world existing parents, believing that absence of an
electronic device will cause their child to go postal, and reliance on a car
that looks like a four-wheel drive will be enough to get them through a
dangerous mountain drive through a blizzard.
Even more clueless is Cady’s aunt Gemma, who inherits her
niece after the deaths of Cady’s parents. The film frankly depicts Gemma’s
ineptitude as a guardian - despite being a toy designer, she barely knows how
to communicate with a little girl, even her own niece. In another swipe at the
inadequacy of technology as replacement for everything, Gemma has to wait for a
bedtime story to download on her smartphone because she doesn’t have any books,
but the film also refreshingly brings us an authentic depiction of a woman who
is not at all maternal (yes, they do exist). What Gemma and Cady do end up
bonding over is Cady’s own drawing efforts and interest in Gemma’s old college
project, a robot called Bruce. This in turn inspires Gemma to abandon a less
interesting deadline and nail down a prototype she is more passionate about.
She works solidly on the life-size doll-robot to produce M3gan, in what she
hopes to be a kill-two-birds-with-one-stone effort at driving through an
ambitious project at work and also appease her bereaved niece.
M3gan is an instant hit, both with Cady and with Gemma’s
boss. Even a sticky moment when Cady breaks down in tears during a display for
the board is overcome in style. M3gan turns it around when she successfully
consoles Cady and rescues the presentation, proving her/it-self to be even more
valuable than anyone expected and sealing the bond even more with Cady.
If a toy being used as replacement for parenting was dubious
enough, M3gan goes above and beyond, showing that she is able to do more
than any parent. Herein lies a pertinent quandary facing all those responsible
for children right now, as the temptation to allow them to learn everything
they need to know via the internet can be all too easily given in to. M3gan is
inextricably linked to the seductive but impersonal possibilities of the
internet – she needs to know everything, always be one step ahead, and, like an
algorithm, be constantly adapting to changing human interests. She proves to be
hard to keep up with, performing one function one moment before switching to an
entirely different one the next in a way that would be deemed psychopathic in a
human.
But so goes what would seem to be a perfect arrangement,
with Gemma unburdened of caring for her ward, and Cady seemingly flourishing
with a new best friend. Linda Hamilton’s observations on Arnold
Schwarzenegger’s android in Terminator 2 are called to mind, when she sees her
son fall in love with the most reliable father figure a child could have. M3gan
takes this role about 50 times further, providing Cady with a companion and
tutor as well as a protector. The latter is where things get dangerous, as any harm
visited upon Cady creates a major grudge in her new pal’s hard drive. The
neighbour’s dog bites Cady so that’s the end of him. But when a hate-filled
bully boy gets heavy with Cady at some dastardly open day for an alternative
school, things get human-murderous.
Like all of the characters in the film, the over-indulged,
violent misogynist in the making that is the bully boy is very well written. If
you have been unfortunate enough to have encountered such a type, it will ring
some very resonant bells. Left partnered and alone with the boy in the woods,
Cady is soon exposed to his rough treatment until M3gan shows up and his
attention is diverted. Turning his less than delicate touch on to the doll and
lifting up her skirts, naturally he gets way more than he bargained for. The
filmmakers don’t mind indulging us in some neatly dark retaliation, as M3gan
displays some of her most deliciously deranged moves. From ominous stillness in
the cold, misty light of the forest, she takes to all fours and gallops like a
rabid animal, a similarly grotesque distortion of a sweet little girl in shades
of Regan in The Exorcist.
As with Yul Brynner’s monstrous robot in Westworld, the film
creators of M3gan understand the disturbing physicality of a fantasy object
made odd by sophisticated physicality that is still visibly unnatural. M3gan is
cute in theory but, as with the robots in Westworld, it’s the eyes that first give
it away. As expertly as she has been designed, the creators still haven’t got
past the dead glass eyes that even the most beloved dolls always have. In true
uncanny fashion, M3gan is repeatedly viewed as acceptable and harmless from a
distance but unnerving close up. And even when M3gan isn’t behaving badly but
doing what she’s supposed to, she can be hilariously weird in a way that only children
and fans of modern music will accept, as demonstrated when she comforts Cady
with her saccharine rendition of popular song ‘Titanium’. Her perversity is
explored to its fullest though when she dances provocatively like a child
beauty pageant contestant in front of Gemma’s boss, before slaughtering him
mercilessly with a paper cutter (this as well as M3gan’s physicality throughout
the film are owed entirely to the exquisite choreography and smart dexterity of
Amie Donald, cast to enact the body of M3gan).
Aside from all the fun though, M3gan has significant things
to say about the dehumanising aspects of over reliance on technology. Even
before she realises how dangerous M3gan is, Gemma recognises that the doll is
not helping Cady deal with grief as she had hoped it would. Feeling better is
important, but what M3gan and other forms of reality escaping would seem to
advocate is an intolerance of suffering at all. In not dealing with the
unfortunate essentialism of suffering, Cady finds herself struggling to relate
to other human beings. It is also Cady’s prevention from confronting grief that
feeds M3gan’s unwieldy impulses, as after all, M3gan is a reactive
product that is fuelled by technologically bonding with a child, and said child
hasn’t had the chance to develop a mature conception of psychological pain. So
it goes, neither does M3gan …
Ultimately and even after the happy ending when all has been
taken care of, the film ends with a pointed shot of Gemma’s virtual assistant
voice service (something that a lot of people already use in the real world
that begins with ‘A’ to give you a clue) as if to warn that we are already on
the journey to such disastrous events if we’re not careful …